Appraisal, Sale Price, CMA, Comps and Assessed Value: Which Number Is Which?
Five terms, five different numbers, and five different people behind them. Here is what each one means, who is responsible for it, and who pays.
The quick take
Five terms get mixed up constantly, and each one answers a different question. The sale price is what the buyer and seller agree on. An appraisal is a licensed appraiser’s opinion of value for the lender. A CMA is your agent’s opinion of what a home is likely to sell for. Comps are the recent sales those opinions are built from. The assessed value is the county’s number for property tax. They are often different numbers for the same house, and that is normal.
Why these get confused
All five are about “what a home is worth,” so people use them interchangeably. But they are made by different people, for different reasons, at different times. A buyer can hear all five in a single week: a CMA before making an offer, a sale price when the offer is accepted, an appraisal from the lender, the assessed value on the county tax notice, and comps in every conversation along the way.
The five terms side by side
| Term | Who creates it | Who pays | What it is used for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | Buyer and seller, through negotiation, with their agents | The buyer pays it to the seller at closing | The deal itself, and the basis for some closing costs and the excise tax |
| Appraisal | A licensed appraiser, working independently. The lender orders it | Usually the buyer, as part of the loan costs | Tells the lender how much the home supports as collateral |
| CMA (comparative market analysis) | A real estate agent or broker, for their client | Usually no charge as part of working with an agent | Pricing a listing, and deciding what to offer |
| Comps (comparable sales) | Pulled from MLS and public records by whoever needs them | Usually no charge | The evidence behind a CMA, an appraisal and often an assessment |
| Assessed value | The county assessor, on the county’s own schedule | No one pays for the value. The owner pays property tax based on it | Calculating the property tax bill |
Sale price
The sale price is the one number that is actually a decision. It is whatever the buyer and seller agree to in the purchase contract. It can be above or below the list price, the CMA, the appraisal and the assessed value. Nobody tells the parties what it must be, and no one can set it for them. Your agent advises, but the buyer and seller make the call. Because it is a negotiated price, it is also the number that becomes recorded history for the home and the next set of comps.
The sale price also drives money. It sets some of the closing costs, and it is the basis for the Washington real estate excise tax, which the seller pays at closing. A higher price means a higher excise tax bill. We cover how that works in our Closing terminology post.
Appraisal
An appraisal is a formal opinion of value written by a licensed appraiser, usually when a buyer is using a loan. The lender orders it, because the lender needs to know the home supports the loan amount if something goes wrong later. Appraisers are expected to work independently, and your agent, the seller and the buyer do not choose the number.
Who orders it: The lender. Buyers do not normally pick the appraiser.
Who pays: Usually the buyer, as part of the costs of getting the loan.
Who does it: A licensed appraiser. It is a formal report, and it relies on comps adjusted for differences in size, condition and features.
What you get: Under federal rules, the lender must give you a free copy of the appraisal promptly, and no later than three business days before closing. Ask for it and read it.
No loan, no appraisal: A buyer paying all cash is not required by a lender to get one, though some buyers order one anyway.
The appraisal is where the other numbers meet reality. If it comes in below the sale price, the buyer faces an appraisal gap. Read more in our post The Appraisal Gap: What Happens When the Home Appraises Low.
CMA (comparative market analysis)
A CMA is an agent’s opinion of what a home is likely to sell for, built from recent comps and the current competition. It is more informal than an appraisal. A good CMA looks at condition, updates, lot, view and timing, and often gives a range rather than a single number.
Who does it: A real estate agent or broker, usually for a seller who is pricing a listing or a buyer who is deciding what to offer.
Who pays: Usually no one. Agents typically prepare it as part of working with you. Ask if you are unsure.
What it is not: An appraisal. A lender does not use it in place of one, and it is an opinion, not a guarantee.
Comps (comparable sales)
Comps are recent sales of homes similar to yours in size, age, condition and location. They are the raw material. Agents use them to build a CMA, appraisers use them to support an appraisal, and owners use them to challenge an assessed value. Because someone has to decide which sales are truly similar, two people can look at the same neighborhood and choose different comps. That is one reason their numbers can differ.
No single person is responsible for comps. Whoever is making the opinion chooses them, and a good professional can explain why those sales were picked and what was adjusted.
Assessed value
The assessed value is the county’s estimate of the property’s value, used to calculate property tax. In King County, the Assessor sets it each year and mails a value notice. Each property’s share of the property tax bill is based on its assessed value. It is not an opinion of what the home would sell for today, and it does not decide the sale price or the appraisal.
Who does it: The county assessor, not your agent, lender or an appraiser you hire.
Who pays: No one pays for the value. The owner pays property tax, which is calculated from it.
If you disagree: You can appeal to the King County Board of Equalization. The petition is due by the later of July 1 of the assessment year or 60 days from the mailing date on your value notice. Check your notice for the exact date, because it is strictly enforced.
One house, five numbers
Take a home that is listed for $825,000. Here is how all five might look. These numbers are invented to show how they differ.
- The county assessed value on the tax notice is $720,000.
- The listing agent’s CMA suggests a range of $810,000 to $830,000, based on comps from the last few months.
- Those comps are four recent nearby sales between $803,000 and $834,000.
- The buyer and seller agree on a sale price of $825,000.
- The lender’s appraisal comes in at $815,000, using its own comps.
Nothing is wrong here. Each number answers a different question. The $10,000 difference between the sale price and the appraisal is an appraisal gap, and that is the one that affects the deal, because the lender will lend based on the lower figure.
Who is responsible for what
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Who decides the sale price? | The buyer and the seller, together |
| Who decides the appraised value? | The appraiser, independently. The lender orders it |
| Who prepares the CMA? | The agent or broker, for their client |
| Who chooses the comps? | Whoever is making the opinion: the agent, the appraiser or the owner |
| Who sets the assessed value? | The county assessor |
| Who pays for the appraisal? | Usually the buyer, as part of the loan costs |
| Who pays for the CMA? | Usually no one, as part of working with an agent |
| Who pays property tax based on the assessed value? | The owner |
| Who pays excise tax based on the sale price? | The seller, at closing |
From our experience
We have seen owners surprised that their county tax value was well below what their home sold for, and buyers surprised that an appraisal came in under their agreed price. In both cases the numbers were doing their jobs. They just had different jobs.
What this means if you are buying
- Use the CMA and the comps to decide what to offer. Do not use the assessed value as a guide to the price.
- Expect the lender to order an appraisal, and plan for what you would do if it comes in below the sale price.
- Ask for your free copy of the appraisal and read it.
- Remember that the assessed value is not the same as what your property tax will be, and that it can change after you buy.
What this means if you are selling
- Ask your agent for a CMA with the comps behind it, so you can see why a price makes sense.
- Do not price your home from the assessed value. It serves a different purpose.
- Be ready for the appraisal. If it lands below your sale price, the buyer may ask to renegotiate or bring more cash.
- Remember that your sale price sets your excise tax, so ask your agent for an estimate of what you will net.
- Keep records of updates and improvements. They help an agent and an appraiser see what makes your home different from the comps.
Questions to ask your agent
- Which comps did you choose, and why those?
- How is your CMA different from what an appraiser will do?
- How likely is it that this home appraises at the sale price?
- What is the assessed value, and does it matter for this decision?
Want the full list of terms?
See our plain-English glossary of real estate terms: www.kellyazzarello.com/jargon
Questions? We are glad to help.
If any of this raises a question about your own situation, reach out. If you need an answer faster, call and we will talk it through.
Kelly Azzarello Real Estate | Compass
Email: kelly@kellyazzarello.com
Phone: (425) 830-6457
Web: www.kellyazzarello.com
Sources and credits
We looked to NWMLS first and then Compass. Neither publishes a plain-language comparison of these terms, so the points above draw on the sources below, in our own words. All dollar figures are invented examples. General information only, not legal or financial advice. Confirm current details with your agent, lender or the county, since rules change.
- Northwest Multiple Listing Service (NWMLS)
- Freedom Mortgage, Comparative Market Analysis
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Delivery of appraisals under the ECOA Valuations Rule
- King County Board of Equalization, Appeal Property Tax
- Manaky, Property Tax Appeals in King County
- Washington Department of Revenue, Real Estate Excise Tax
“As-Is”: What It Does and Does Not Mean
As-is" does not mean "no inspection" and it does not mean "no negotiating." Here is what the phrase really means in Washington.
The quick take
As-is generally means the seller does not plan to make repairs or give credits. It does not stop you from inspecting the home, and it does not erase the seller’s disclosure duties. It does mean you take the home in its current condition.
What "as-is" usually means
When a listing says "as-is," the seller is telling you they do not plan to make repairs or give credits for the condition of the home. You are buying it the way it stands today, and any work that comes up after that is yours to handle.
What it does not mean
• It does not mean you cannot inspect. You can still hire an inspector, and we generally recommend it.
• It does not necessarily mean you cannot negotiate. A seller may still agree to a price change after you learn what is wrong, especially if the home would otherwise go back on the market.
• It does not automatically cancel the seller’s legal duties. In Washington, most residential sellers must provide a Seller Disclosure Statement, known as Form 17.
The seller disclosure still matters
Form 17 asks the seller to answer questions about the property, such as roof, plumbing, and known defects. Some sellers are exempt, such as estate sales, bank-owned properties, trustees, and some new construction. Exempt sellers may still provide a disclosure voluntarily. When a disclosure is required and the buyer receives it, the buyer generally has three business days to rescind the agreement. Details depend on the contract, so review the timing with your agent.
Keep in mind that Form 17 only covers what the seller knows. It does not replace an inspection.
Washington is a "buyer beware" state
Buyers of resale homes generally do not get a warranty from the seller, and it can be hard to hold a seller responsible for a defect unless they misrepresented it. That is why inspection matters, and why waiving an inspection can leave you with limited recourse if something turns up later.
From our experience
We have seen as-is homes that were true opportunities, and others where the inspection found problems that changed the buyer’s plan. Buyers who budgeted for surprises, and who knew their walk-away number before they wrote an offer, were the most comfortable either way.
If you are buying an as-is home
• Inspect the home, and consider specialists such as a sewer scope or a roof or foundation expert if the inspector suggests it.
• Read the seller disclosure carefully, if there is one, and note the three-day window.
• Set aside a repair budget before you offer, and decide what you will do if the number is higher than expected.
• Ask us about the home’s history and about nearby sales.
If you are selling as-is
Selling as-is can simplify things when you do not want to manage repairs, and it can attract buyers who are comfortable with projects. It works best when the price reflects the condition. A pre-listing inspection can help you set expectations, and your agent can walk you through your disclosure duties.
Want the full list of terms?
See our plain-English glossary of real estate terms: www.kellyazzarello.com/jargon
Questions? We are glad to help.
If any of this raises a question about your own situation, reach out. If you need an answer faster, call and we will talk it through.
Sources and credits
We looked to NWMLS first and then Compass. Neither publishes a plain-language definition of this term, so the points above draw on the sources below, in our own words. General information only, not legal or financial advice. Confirm current details with your agent or lender, since forms and rules change.
Madrona Group, What Is Form 17 in Washington
The Appraisal Gap: What Happens When the Home Appraises Low
You agreed to a price, but the appraisal came in lower. Here is what that gap means, how the math works, and what your options are.
The quick take
An appraisal gap is the difference between the price you agreed to pay and a lower appraised value. The lender bases your loan on the appraisal, so you generally need to cover the difference, renegotiate, or walk away, depending on your contract.
What an appraisal gap is
When you buy with a loan, the lender orders an appraisal. A licensed appraiser estimates what the home is worth. The lender will only lend against the appraised value or the price, whichever is lower. If the appraisal comes in below the price you agreed to pay, the difference is the appraisal gap.
It is more common in competitive markets, in rising markets, with unusual homes, and where few similar homes have sold recently. Redfin reports that roughly 8% of appraisals come in below the contract price.
A simple example
This is a simplified example with round numbers. Your loan type and lender rules can change the math.
• You agree to buy a home for $800,000 and plan to put 20% down, which is $160,000, with a $640,000 loan.
• The home appraises at $775,000, which is $25,000 below the price.
• The lender will lend 80% of $775,000, or $620,000, instead of $640,000.
• To close at $800,000, you need $180,000 in cash instead of $160,000. That is $20,000 more than you planned.
Your options
Renegotiate: Ask the seller to lower the price to the appraised value, or to meet in the middle. Sellers sometimes agree, especially if the home would otherwise go back on the market.
Cover the gap: Pay the difference in cash from savings or other eligible funds. This keeps the deal alive, and it is a choice about how much you are willing to pay above appraised value.
Challenge the appraisal: Your lender may be able to request a reconsideration of value, if you have strong comparable sales or evidence of errors. There is no guarantee it will change.
Walk away: If your contract has an appraisal or financing contingency and you act on time, you may be able to cancel and recover your earnest money. Without that protection, you may risk the deposit.
Gap clauses in offers
In competitive situations, buyers sometimes include language promising to cover some or all of a low appraisal. It can make an offer more attractive, and it also means you take on the risk. If you consider it, decide the most you are comfortable paying and put that number in writing.
From our experience
We have seen buyers decide, in advance, that they would cover a specific amount over appraisal, and others decide they would not cover any. Both can be the right call. What matters is deciding before you are in the middle of a deal, with the clock ticking.
What this means if you are selling
A low appraisal can slow or break a sale. A well-supported price, with recent comparable sales that fit your home, makes a low appraisal less likely. Your agent can help you prepare, and can talk through what to do if the number comes in short.
Questions to ask your agent
• Does my offer have an appraisal or financing contingency, and when does it expire?
• How much cash could I bring if the appraisal comes in low?
• What comparable sales support this price?
Want the full list of terms?
See our plain-English glossary of real estate terms: www.kellyazzarello.com/jargon
Questions? We are glad to help.
If any of this raises a question about your own situation, reach out. If you need an answer faster, call and we will talk it through.
Kelly Azzarello Real Estate | Compass
Email: kelly@kellyazzarello.com
Phone: (425) 830-6457
Sources and credits
We looked to NWMLS first and then Compass. Neither publishes a plain-language definition of this term, so the points above draw on the sources below, in our own words. General information only, not legal or financial advice. Confirm current details with your agent or lender, since forms and rules change.
Redfin, What Is an Appraisal Gap?
Madrona Group, What Is a Financing Contingency in Washington
Earnest Money: Your Good-Faith Deposit, Explained
Earnest money is not an extra fee. It is a deposit toward your purchase, and it can be at risk if you miss a deadline. Here is how it works
The quick take
Earnest money is a good-faith deposit you make after the seller accepts your offer. It is credited toward your purchase at closing. You can lose it if you walk away for a reason the contract does not protect, so deadlines matter.
What earnest money is
Earnest money is a deposit that shows the seller you are serious. You give it after your offer is accepted, and if the sale closes, it is credited toward the money you owe at closing, usually your down payment and closing costs. It is not an extra fee. It is a part of your purchase money that moves in early.
How much is typical?
There is no legal minimum or maximum in Washington, so the amount is negotiated. The sources we looked at put typical deposits in a range from about 1% to 5% of the purchase price, and in competitive situations a larger deposit can make an offer look stronger. On an $800,000 home, 1% to 5% would be $8,000 to $40,000. Your agent can help you pick an amount that fits your situation.
| Home price | 1% | 2% | 3% | 5% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500,000 | $5,000 | $10,000 | $15,000 | $25,000 |
| $800,000 | $8,000 | $16,000 | $24,000 | $40,000 |
| $1,000,000 | $10,000 | $20,000 | $30,000 | $50,000 |
Examples only. In Washington the amount is negotiated, with no legal minimum or maximum. Your agent can help you choose a number that fits your situation.
When is it due, and who holds it?
The timing is spelled out in your purchase and sale agreement, and it is usually within a couple of days after both sides have signed. Missing that deadline can put you in default, so plan ahead and know how you will pay.
You do not hand the money to the seller. A neutral party holds it, typically the escrow company, or in some cases the buyer’s brokerage in a trust account. Escrow generally cannot release the funds to either side without both parties’ written agreement or a court order.
When you get it back, and when you can lose it
Usually refundable: If you cancel under a contingency in your contract, such as inspection or financing, and you give notice on time and in the right form, your deposit is generally returned.
At risk: If you walk away for a reason the contract does not cover, if you miss a contingency deadline, or if you waived a protection to make your offer more competitive.
The standard Washington purchase and sale form also asks the parties to choose how a buyer default is handled. One option limits the seller’s remedy to keeping the deposit. The other lets the seller pursue additional remedies. Which one is checked in your contract matters, so read that section with your agent.
From our experience
We have seen disputes over a deposit that came down to a missed deadline or a notice that was not delivered correctly. The safest habit is to put every contingency date on a calendar the day your offer is accepted, and to deliver notices exactly as the contract says.
Tips for buyers
• Know the deadline and have the funds ready before you write the offer.
• Put every contingency deadline on your calendar on day one.
• Waiving protections to win an offer also puts your deposit at risk. Talk it through first.
• If there is a disagreement, do not assume you can simply ask for the money back. Both sides usually need to sign off, so get advice early.
This post is general information, not legal advice. For a specific default or dispute, a Washington real estate attorney is the right call.
Want the full list of terms?
See our plain-English glossary of real estate terms: www.kellyazzarello.com/jargon
Questions? We are glad to help.
If any of this raises a question about your own situation, reach out. If you need an answer faster, call and we will talk it through.
Kelly Azzarello Real Estate | Compass
Email: kelly@kellyazzarello.com
Phone: (425) 830-6457
Sources and credits
We looked to NWMLS first and then Compass. Neither publishes a plain-language definition of this term, so the points above draw on the sources below, in our own words. General information only, not legal or financial advice. Confirm current details with your agent or lender, since forms and rules change.
Contingent vs. Pending
You found a home you love and the status says contingent or pending. Is it gone? Here is what the labels mean and what you can still do.
The quick take
Contingent means the seller accepted an offer, but a condition is still open. Pending means the conditions are mostly cleared and the sale is heading to closing. Neither means the door is shut, and the exact label matters more than the word on a portal.
Why this is so confusing
If you have browsed homes on a national website, you have probably seen "contingent" and "pending" used as if they mean the same thing. They do not, and the agent-side listing system shows even more detail than the public portals do. In our area, that system is the Northwest Multiple Listing Service (NWMLS).
NWMLS statuses are labels that agents use to describe where a listing stands. They do not tell you every term of the deal, and the portals that display them can show them differently or a little late. Your agent sees the official status, which is one reason to ask before you give up on a home.
What the labels generally mean
Active: The home is available for showings and offers.
Contingent: An offer has been accepted, but the deal still depends on something. In the NWMLS, this label is commonly described as meaning the buyer first needs to sell their own home. The property may stay on the market, and another buyer can sometimes step in.
Pending Inspection: The buyer is still in the inspection period. This is a stage where deals most often change, because inspection findings can lead to repairs, credits, or a buyer backing out.
Pending: The buyer and seller have a signed agreement and the main conditions have been cleared. The sale is moving toward closing, although it can still fall apart.
Pending Feasibility: Similar to Pending Inspection, but used mostly for land or properties that need studies before anything can be built.
Back on market: A prior sale did not close and the home is available again.
Graphic of the activity ladder. Note that not all steps are included in all transactions.
Because definitions vary a bit from one source to the next, treat this list as a guide and confirm the exact status and terms with your agent.
Can you still make an offer?
Sometimes, yes. Here are the three most common ways:
• A back-up offer. Some sellers will accept offers behind the first buyer. If the first deal fails, the back-up moves up.
• A bump clause. If the first buyer’s offer depends on selling their own home, the seller may keep marketing and give that buyer a deadline to remove the condition or step aside when a better offer arrives.
• Waiting. Deals do fall through, and a home that went contingent or pending can return to active within days.
From our experience
We have watched homes go to pending inspection on a Friday and back to active the following week after the buyer and seller could not agree on repairs. Buyers who stayed in touch with their agent, and who were ready with a pre-approval, were able to move quickly.
What this means if you are buying
• Do not write off a home because of its status. Ask your agent what the status really means for that listing.
• If you want to be in line, ask whether the seller is taking back-up offers and what that would look like.
• Keep your financing pre-approved and current. If a home reopens, you want to be able to move the same day.
What this means if you are selling
Your listing status is part of your marketing. A "pending" label tells other buyers to look elsewhere, while "contingent" can leave the door open to back-up interest. Talk with your agent about which choice fits your goals, and make sure the status is updated promptly when anything changes.
Questions to ask your agent
• What exactly does this status mean on this listing?
• Is the seller accepting back-up offers?
• What condition is still open, and when does it have to be cleared?
• Has this home been on and off the market before?
Want the full list of terms?
See our plain-English glossary of real estate terms: www.kellyazzarello.com/jargon
Questions? We are glad to help.
If any of this raises a question about your own situation, reach out. If you need an answer faster, call and we will talk it through.
Kelly Azzarello Real Estate | Compass
Email: kelly@kellyazzarello.com
Phone: (425) 830-6457
Sources and credits
We looked to NWMLS first and then Compass. Neither publishes a plain-language definition of this term, so the points above draw on the sources below, in our own words. General information only, not legal or financial advice. Confirm current details with your agent or lender, since forms and rules change.
Northwest Multiple Listing Service (NWMLS)
Findwell, Understanding Pending Status for Homes Listed in the Northwest MLS
Real Estate Speak, Decoded: Start Here
New to real estate language? Start here. Kelly Azzarello Real Estate explains the terms, the process and the risks in plain English.
Unless you’re part of the real estate industry, or your family is, chances are there is a lot of terminology that is not familiar.
A big part of the value we provide our clients is explaining the words, the process, and the risks and rewards available in the real estate arena.
This series will walk you through not only the terms, but some stories behind what we’ve learned from our experiences in the business.
If you have any questions or suggestions, let us know and we’ll figure it out.
But if you need an answer faster, reach out and we’ll have a conversation about it.

